What makes something a PFIC?
A passive foreign investment company is any foreign corporation that meets one of two tests. Either 75% or more of its gross income is passive. Or 50% or more of its assets, on average, produce passive income.
A fund earning dividends, interest and capital gains meets both comfortably.
Why does an Indian mutual fund get caught?
Indian mutual funds are not named anywhere in the US statute. They get there by default.
A foreign vehicle whose investors all have limited liability is treated as a corporation for US tax purposes unless someone elects otherwise. Nobody elects otherwise for a retail Indian mutual fund. So it is a foreign corporation earning passive income, which is a PFIC.
What does it actually cost you?
Under the default regime, your gain is spread back across the whole time you held the fund. Each earlier year is taxed at that year's top marginal rate, currently 37%. No capital-gains rate. No deductions to offset it.
On top of that, interest is charged, compounding daily.
And the clock never starts. A normal tax year closes after three years. A year with an unfiled PFIC form stays open indefinitely, however long ago it was.
Is there a way out?
Two elections exist. Only one is realistic for Indian funds.
- QEF election. Needs an annual information statement from the fund in US tax form. Indian AMCs do not produce one, so this is rarely available.
- Mark-to-market election. Available where the shares are regularly traded or redeemable at a published daily NAV, which most Indian mutual funds are. You pay tax on the paper gain each year, as ordinary income. Painful, but far better than the default.
What is not a PFIC?
This is the useful part, and almost nobody says it.
The PFIC rules reach foreign corporations. An ordinary Indian operating company — a bank, a manufacturer — fails both tests, so its shares are not a PFIC.
So a PMS invested in operating-company shares creates no PFIC exposure at all. You hold the shares directly, in your own name. You still report the account, but the punitive regime does not apply.
The exception: if the mandate holds mutual fund units, PFIC comes back for those holdings. Ask for the mandate in writing.
I already own them and never filed anything
You are not unusual, and there is a defined route back. The IRS streamlined filing procedures exist for people whose failure was not deliberate.
Waiting does not help, because those years never closed. Take the fund statements to a US tax professional. The analysis is per fund, per year.